Jesus Database logo
working together for the future of faith
 

 

Hating One's Family

Data

(1a) Thom 55:1-2a
(1b) Thom 101
(2) 1Q: Luke 14:25-26 = Matt 10:37

 

Texts

(1a) Thom 55:1-2a

55 Jesus said, "Whoever does not hate father and mother cannot be my disciple, 2 and whoever does not hate brothers and sisters, and carry the cross as I do, will not be worthy of me." [Complete Gospels]

 

(1b) Thom 101

101 "Whoever does not hate [father] and mother as I do cannot be my [disciple], 2 and whoever does [not] love [father and] mother as I do cannot be my [disciple]. 3For my mother [. . .], but my true [mother] gave me life." [Complete Gospels]

 

(2) Luke 14:25-26

14:25 Now large crowds were traveling with him; and he turned and said to them, 14:26 "Whoever comes to me and does not hate father and mother, wife and children, brothers and sisters, yes, and even life itself, cannot be my disciple.

= Matt 10:37
10:37 Whoever loves father or mother more than me is not worthy of me; and whoever loves son or daughter more than me is not worthy of me; 10:38 and whoever does not take up the cross and follow me is not worthy of me.

 

 

Notes

John Dominic Crossan

Item: 89
Stratum: I (30-60 CE)
Attestation: Double
Historicity: +
Common Sayings Tradition: Yes

Crossan [Historical Jesus, 299-302] discusses Jesus opposition to the patriarchal family. He observes:

The strife is not between believers and non-believers but quite simply, and as it says, between the generations and in both directions. Jesus will tear the hierarchical or patriarchal family in two along the axis of domination and subordination. Second, and even more significant, is that the division imagined cuts across sex and gender. (p. 300)

 

Jesus Seminar

Text

Item

 Source

JS Mtg

%Red

%Pink

%Gray

%Black

W Avg

Color

Thom 55:1-2a
71
Q, T
87StP
5
18
45
32
0.32
Gray
 
71
Q, T
89Tor
22
13
56
9
0.49
Gray
Thom 101:1-3
71
Q, T
87StP
0
5
9
86
0.06
Black
 
71
Q, T
89Tor
6
12
18
64
0.20
Black
Luke 14:25-26
71
Q, T
87StP
4
30
43
22
0.39
Gray
 
71
Q, T
87StP
27
18
48
6
0.56
Pink
Matt 10:37
71
Q, T
87StP
0
22
43
35
0.29
Gray
 
71
Q, T
89Tor
22
44
25
0.39
Gray

The commentary in The Five Gospels observes:

This saying, which must have been offensive to Jesus' audience when he first enunciated it, has suffered the fate of other harsh sayings in the tradition. Matthew softens it by making the love of family subordinate to the love of Jesus. But Luke and Thomas retain the rigorous form: hatred of family is a condition of discipleship.

The severity of this saying can only be understood in the context of the primacy of filial relationships. Individuals had no real existence apart from their ties to blood relatives, especially parents. If one did not belong to a family, one had no real social existence. Jesus is therefore confronting the social structures that governed society at their core For Jesus, family ties faded into insignificance in relation to God's imperial rule, which he regarded as the fundamental claim on human loyalty. (p. 353)

Abbreviations | Bibliography | Copyright | FFF Home | Get Involved | JDB Home | Search | Email FFF